Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie
Hi there,
There is an issue with role permissions that is being worked on at the moment.
If you are having trouble with access or permissions on regional forums please post here to get access: https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058365403/you-do-not-have-permission-for-that#latest

The main thing is keeping the main thing, the main thing

1818284868793

Comments

  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D




  • Registered Users Posts: 361 ✭✭babacool




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    Marathon Week.

    Monday: A nice few miles down to the PP & 7 strides, getting progressively faster. Really felt good.

    6.15 miles.

    Tuesday: 3m Progressive Tempo - 10 mins WU - 3 miles getting slightly faster each mile (6.20/6.14/6.11) - 10 mins CD. As per all tapers, this felt a bit tough.

    What a great workout - done and dusted in 40 mins.

    6m total.

    Wednesday: Rest day.

    Thursday: a few easy miles and some longer strides - 5x30 secs.

    Everything in a good place.

    5.3 miles

    Friday: Travel day - over to Seville, nice flight, nice hotel. Walked around for a couple of hours in the town. What a lovely city.

    Saturday: Went to the expo to get my number - very well organised - in and out in no time.

    Done a couple of miles plus more strides to see the start line and get a view of how long it takes to get there (answer - 5 mins from my hotel)

    2.9 miles + strides.

    Met up with a few running buddies for a bit of pizza and back to the hotel to watch the Tottenham match - always good to beat Man City.

    I had brought some precision hydration sachets and salt tabs - so made sure I was nicely topped up.

    Gear ready, number pinned, shoes primed.

    All ready for action.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 220 ✭✭E.coli


    Tease 😅



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    Thought you told me you had the race report prewritten??



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    Seville 2022

    "My ONLY motivation for doing Seville is to keep motivated over the winter and get some good sessions in - whatever time I run on the day will reflect that - Not putting any pressure on myself again - I dont think the stomach ulcers can handle it!" AMK Nov 5th 2021

    The above quote became subject to Mission Creep as the weeks went on and came back to me both during the race and afterwards.

    "The best race on the day" is another way of looking at this. This was very helpful to me as the race unfolded - especially outside my Hotel at mile 22.

    Sunday Feb 20th - Seville.

    The morning of the race arrived - I got up at 5.50 Local time (4.50am Irish time as I kept telling my family) - Breakfast was a light affair, followed a bit later with a Maurten drink and a drink from Precision Hydration that included a lot of Salts, Magnesium and Potassium. 3 additional salt tabs, just before the start line and I was ready to rock.

    Made my way to the start line and met my 2 buddies AJ & PM - dropped a bag and went to the start line - all very seamless and very well organised.

    The starting pen was for 2.45-3.00 but there was a 3.30hr and even a 4.30 Pacer balloon in the our pen. I was quite a few rows back - but was not worried at all. It seemed a bit surreal that I was about to run a Marathon - it just seemed to catch up with me all of a sudden - I don't think I was mentally prepared for it - I considered this a positive as I had no nerves or apprehension.

    My plan was to run as close to 6.25 per mile average for the full event (I had another marker for 20 min 5ks all the way through).

    0-5km: 20:07 (Miles 1-3 6:33/6.24/6.25) - Finding my line.

    We were set off and there was about 20 seconds on the clock as I passed under it.

    I had promised myself that my 1st couple of miles would be my slowest and all going well, my 1st 5k would be my slowest 5k of the race. As I set off - I was moving through the field and trying to find a line - I noted that there were no mile markers - just KMs - so much for being Auld.

    I think the most memorable thing for the 1st 5k was going over a bridge.

    I recall the 1st water station being cups - I took 1 to trial it - worked ok but not great.


    5km-10km: 19.53 (Miles 4-6: 6.22/6.24/6.23) - 'More than 2 hours of this $hit left'

    The next few miles felt ok - I do remember checking my watch prior to the 8k mark saying to myself - "more than 2 more hours of this ****" - This set the mindset for the remainder of the event - unlike Rotterdam and even San Sebastian (I got bored in those races) - this was just pure disinterest so early in the race - I wasn't looking forward to it at all and the thoughts of running for that long really played with my mind.

    The 2nd water stop was in bottles, so I got a good swig and pored some over my head as I noted it was starting to get a bit warm. I took a caffeine gel at 25 mins.

    Went through 10km in 40 mins.

    10km-15km: 19.52 (Miles 7-9: 6.22/6.28/6.21) - Finding joy in company

    As I approached the 10km mark - I noted a guy ahead in a Rathfarnham top who appeared to be in conversation with another lad. I'll have some of that I thought - it might help with the mindset.

    I caught up with him (Colm) and started having a chat - turned out he knew the guy & lady I had dinner with the previous night (Paul M & AJ) and he was part of the famous Jerry Kiernan Harriers group.

    We had a good chat for a few miles - nothing too heavy - and sometimes just a few words, as we settled in with a good group who were chasing a similar goal.

    I remember thinking about Rotterdam - at a similar stage, I felt like I was jogging - at this stage, I didn't feel like I was jogging - it felt comfortable - but steady comfortable rather than easy comfortable.

    Another Maurten gel at about 8 miles (50 mins).

    15km-20km: 19.52 (Miles 10-12: 6.29/6.26/6.26) - Teamwork makes the dream work

    We were in the group now and not really checking time/pace - the group was moving nicely along and I was taking on whatever water I could in those pesky cups.

    Nothing too dramatic here - I'm still with Colm, still in the group and working nicely. The company really helped with those last few miles as did the group.

    Another caffeine gel at about the 12m mark - I felt like I was continually eating gels at this stage!

    20km-25km: 19.48 (Miles 13-15: 6.16/6.17/6.21) - Things happen in 3's

    3 key things happened in this 5k that in hindsight impacted the rest of the race. This is the key part of the race where I question my decision making.

    Firstly - Colm announces that its getting a bit hot for him and he's going to drop back - He was pacing his buddy to half way and he reached that, so was pulling back a bit. ( I should have followed him)

    Secondly, the crowd we were running with seemed to also dissipate and as a result, I was running on my own.

    Thirdly - the GPS seemed to get quite messed up for a few miles - I noted paces of 5.55 on my watch for patches of the run as I approached the half way point.

    At halfway - I was amazed to see the clock read 1.25.30 ( I knew I had about 20 seconds on this from starting a bit back - but still - I thought I was much move ahead given the splits. (Strava gave me a HM split of 1.23.41 - which seemed to match my splits and effort)

    The GPS was all over the place for a while - so I was just guessing my pace and had no group to pace off - people seemed to be passing me, so I guessed I was going ok??

    I recall thinking at this stage - while actually running very well) that this would be my last Marathon - while I enjoyed the training - I wasn't enjoying the race. This would be it.

    In hindsight (isn't it wonderful) - I was amazed to see the mile splits back at me - far too fast I know - but at the time, it was difficult to know if they were accurate. Another gel taken here.

    25km-30km: 20.03 (Miles 16-18: 6.22/6.20/6.35) - The beginning of the race

    The next couple of miles mirrored the last few - far too quick - and I kept trying to take on water in cups, but you can only take on so much. I was staring to feel the heat now and I was starting to see people walking and stopping.

    This is the beginning of the race I thought.

    At about mile 16 I felt the beginnings of a discomfort in my left quad, wasn't hindering me but I noticed it. As mile 18 approached, I noted my right shin was starting to cramp - this was something I noted previously after some faster sessions, but not in a Marathon (apart from the infamous Dublin Marathon when everything cramped).

    I took some of my 'Hotshot' drink and reduced the pace a bit and the shin issue went away, but the left quad was becoming more of a hindrance. I was going to have to reduce the pace or risk a bigger issue.

    My 30k split shows up on Strava as my fastest ever (1.59.26)

    30km-35km: 22.06 (Miles 19-21: 6.37/7.04/7.19) - Hello Cramp my old friend.

    This 5k would be quite tough - the 'quick' 5 miles from 13 to 17 would come back to haunt me here.

    At about 19.4 miles (from Strava - where my pace dropped) - I got my 1st real cramp of the race. As I felt it coming on - I took my hotshot thinking that would fix it and I'd keep going - It didn't make 1 bit of difference as the cramp took over my right hammy - I tried punching it similar to Rotterdam - but it was strange, it was if I couldn't really care if I cramped as I didn't have the mental fortitude to attack it as I had in Rotterdam and previously in Dublin. I was kinda slapping it.

    In hindsight (theres that word again) - I had put so much stock in my Salt strategy and my magic elixirs that I actually though I wouldn't cramp - so when it came - I was kinda gutted and even more so when the Hotshot didn't work. - it really knocked me. I had a 2nd magic elixir called Cramp Fix - it was also 1 year out of date, so I was keeping it for a 'just in case' - and this was my 'just in case'. I took it and noted a reprieve so I could keep going.

    But I was bleeding time here. Another sniper fired a shot at 20.6 miles - just before the park - I stepped off the course to stretch it out as punching it wasn't working (I dont think I was really punching it - kinda slapping again). I took more Cramp fix and the ramp went away - I got going again.

    What was interesting was that when the cramp went - I could pick up the pace a bit - my left quad was still an issue, so I was managing that as well.

    Good grief - at least I wasn't bored or disinterested I thought (& smiled)

    35km-40km: 22.34 (Miles 22-24: 7.27/7.15/7.01) - This is the End

    We left the park - I felt I was running 10 min/miles at this stage and I came along a familiar road - close to my hotel - actually - it was going by my hotel. Right outside my Hotel, and I mean, right outside it - I got another cramp and I considered calling it a day - I couldn't face another 30 mins or so of this. I was just about to press my Garmin and I thought about my daughters - would they want to hear about their dad quitting when things got tough?

    I thought about a conversation I had with Johnny on the Saturday when I told him I was going to finish it no matter what.

    I thought about the massive support I had gotten all the way through this training block - the many well wishes on Saturday flooded my brain at this stage.

    All the above happened in a matter of seconds as my hand hovered over my watch - Fcuk it - lets go and finish this I thought.

    "The best race on the day means exactly that".

    The next 2 miles I actually enjoyed - I was picking up the pace - I began to think of different goals - maybe sub 2.55 is possible - if not - then a sub 2.58 will be the 2nd fastest Marathon you've ran. Both great goals and both kept me going.

    The course got really interesting now as we were going through the old town and down side streets - this is fantastic I was thinking. Finally - I had woken up.

    40km-42km (Miles 25-26.58: 7.03/7.10/ 4.53 (8.24 pace for last bit) - Just open the fcuking thing

    The last couple of KM of this race is just MAD - the crowd comes in on you as the streets get narrow, theres multiple trip hazards with steps on your left and right, and there are about a million arch's that you go through - I was waiting to see 800m to go on every arch, but no.

    I finally turned onto what I knew to be the finishing straight - Can I get a 2.56 finish I thought? I was pushing and noted a twinge in my right hamstring again - always the right hamstring - I punched it - actually gave it a proper punch this time as I could see the finish line but I think this made it worse - I had to stop - even though I could ee the finish line 200m ahead - I couldn't even hobble.

    Then a funny moment in the chaos - A guy came over to me with a pouch that he was trying to open, I thought it was a cream for my cramp - and he was struggling to open it - I was shouting at him to open the damn thing. Eventually he opened it but it was one of those silver reflective things that you put over yourself at the end of the race - I told him to Fcuk off that I wanted to finish - my cramp semi subsided and I hobbled across the finish line.

    Time: 2.57.20


    The aftermath:

    So - while not the time I wanted - I took so many learning's from this race, which I'll detail in another post.

    I do want to acknowledge the many many people who took the time to post a comment on Strava, Social Media etc - its so much appreciated and stays with me - so thank you - I get kinda embarrassed with some of it - but hey ho. I even got a video message from the Curragh Plains :)

    The race itself - with the exception of the water in Cups - it was fantastic and I would love to & will run it again, under a different mindset.

    I think back to a few months ago - sitting in a hospital bed, thinking that my running career was over, pulling out of Manchester as a result - so in this light, I'm extremely proud to finish the race. This is the dominant feeling in the aftermath.

    My 2 girls also got me a card when I got home, saying how proud they were of me for finishing a mentally and physically bruising race - that meant so much to me and reiterates the decision to finish was always going to be correct.

    I also got a lovely message from DD saying I'd have laughed if I said a few years back, I'd cramp a few times in a race and still manage a comfortable sub 3 - that's quite the true statement.

    I met up with a lot of the Jerry K Harriers later that night and had such a wonderful night with them, swapping war stories - I spoke with Mark Kirwan (who was a 2.17 DCM guy at one stage) and Dave Mansfield (who ran 2.16 in Seville) - along with a plethora of guys & gals who had similar experiences similar to myself. I actually ended up going for dinner with Colm (from the race - he ran 2.55 - and also sitting beside him on the plane home :) - lovely fella)

    The only people who care about your Marathon time is you - that's true - but there are a lot of people who are very interested in the journey you took to get there - that's the interesting part and that's what we covered a lot in that bar in Seville and also what interests us here in this fabulous running community on Boards.

    Seville - you were great - you taught me a lot, more than any Marathon I've ever done and I'll be back to repay you.





  • That part about the guy in the last part of the race gave me a good giggle. I can just imagine.

    People would give their eye teeth for a 2.57 marathon in their lifetime.

    Its a remarkable achievement to go sub 3.

    Surely with the fine weather and daylight coming in soon we hope, you'll be up to challenge

    your result in DCM.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 220 ✭✭E.coli


    Delighted to see this reaction to the race. Your quote is quite poignant as well. The fact us you came through the winter in great shape and despite the clock not reflecting it on the day you still have that fitness to kick on from.

    Regarding the cramps, without getting into the controversial side of the man the following quote still stands

    "How did it feel to fail 1,000 times?" Edison replied, "I didn't fail 1,000 times. The light bulb was an invention with 1,000 steps." 

    When you do click it you are going to be as smug as anything as you will smash it because the fitness you continue to build up is not going away. All these blocks will stand to you in the long run



  • Registered Users Posts: 2,831 ✭✭✭Annie get your Run


    There won't be a dry eye in the house! I presume that won't be your last marathon though?! A brilliant report Alan. AJ got me into running many years ago, no better company to have. Sounds like a fantastic experience despite the hurt and what doesn't kill you etc etc. Well done again.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,505 ✭✭✭Laineyfrecks


    Great marathon A & even better report. I admire anyone who digs deep(whatever the time they finish in) & when they put it into words like yours well it just hits home more. We have all had great races & race reports to match but when things don't go exactly to plan it's not so easy to put into words but you captured it all. Your journey was great to follow as always. Well done again.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 1,761 ✭✭✭ReeReeG


    That's a great race report. Sorry it wasn't the race you had hoped for, but a real display of resilience here. Very well done on finishing it out, you should be very proud of yourself! And how amazing to still get a sub 3, savage.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,306 ✭✭✭ariana`


    Love it. Love the honesty, the humour, the pain and mostly the pride. It really is something when you can run sub 3 on a bad day. Imagine that! You are a remarkable runner, father, friend... you will get your day but for now enjoy being proud of the day you had on Sunday.

    On another note Seville marathon is really tempting, it's now firmly on my list though I wonder if it would get a bit warm for a 3:30-4:00 hr marathon runner. My brother lived there for a year to train way back, probably 25 years ago now, he cycled over with his ruck back on his back and spent a year warm weather training and doing a bit of bar work to support himself. Oh to be young.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    Great report A. My initial reaction when I saw the Strava update was "Feck, he's gonna be gutted". No disrespect to the achievement. Sub 3, even on a good day, is a phenomenal achievement. I just saw the "c word" and knew that was the main thing you wanted to address and avoid this time.

    However, the race report tells a different story. It really does seem like you took a lot from that race in terms of learning. I guess I was half expecting the cramp appeared out of nowhere with no real warning but you seem to at least have some handle on why it happened. I'm looking forward to seeing your post on the learnings from the training/marathon itself.

    Huge kudos for gritting it out. Love the way you thought of your family and especially your daughters. There's a great reason to fight on - teaching them a life lesson in the process.

    It's clear you're hugely popular around these parts. I think the day where you nail it and hit sub 2.50 we'll all celebrate. Preferably in McGrattans but no pressure. 😁.

    Last thing - I remember meeting you in McGrattans after DCM 2018 (i think?). You were delighted with sub 3. Well you just ran 2.57 on a day where you had to walk multiple times. I just can't wait til it all clicks...and it will all click.....



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D


    Well done A, I do think it was a superb achievement to finish in the circumstances, and your man trying to wrap you up in a space blanket short of the finish line - funny as it reads - really does put another perspective on the fortitude displayed to get to the end.

    Your account throws up lots of food for thought too, as it should when things don't go too well. I look forward to that 'learnings' post you've promised. Good that you managed to have a great night out with like-minded people afterwards, which can go a long way towards processing a less-than-hoped-for result.

    Great race report too, plenty of soul in there! Enjoy the recovery/recuperation.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D





  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,379 ✭✭✭diego_b


    That's a fantastic race report and gives a great insight into your race and the race itself. Hoping you get to the root cause of those cramp issues, cracking time to run for your second best marathon especially given the cramping issues over the second half of the race. Well done for keeping going and recover well.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 1,196 ✭✭✭MY BAD


    You're a legend AMK don't change. Great report and like I said you showed great grit. Lots to be proud of there. I think if you get another marathon in later this year you'll hit your goal no problem



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 4,834 ✭✭✭OOnegative


    Great lad for the name dropping…….

    Am not going to blow sunshine up you’re ar$e Alan, because you already know that I think you’re one of the most down to earth, humble, sound and generous with your time people I’ve ever met.

    Don’t change, that performance you’re striving for will come you are to good a runner and to decent of an individual for it not to. Well done!!



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 747 ✭✭✭MisterJinx


    This is a great paragraph "The only people who care about your Marathon time is you - that's true - but there are a lot of people who are very interested in the journey you took to get there - that's the interesting part and that's what we covered a lot in that bar in Seville and also what interests us here in this fabulous running community on Boards" You are 100% right in that the time is really only important to you but it's the journey that is most important, most revealing and ultimately resonates with the community here no matter what level you are at. Seeing the hard work and effort you have put in over the course of this log and then following that up with the insight into your race to frame it all at the end is great read and an inspiration. Well done on the race itself, I could totally picture you at the door to the hotel and how much you wanted to press the button and the through that brought you back from the brink. Considering all the set backs in that race you must be very proud of yourself.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 735 ✭✭✭Treviso


    You see, you don't need to invent stories about giving CPR to a dying dog and saving a lost granny from a rabid child (think I got that right 🤣) to give a great race report. Felt like I was running the marathon with you from all the details. Love how you went from never running a marathon again at the start, to see you again Seville for another one at the finish - normally it's the opposite way round!

    It's a shame that the cramping issues happened again and will be interested to read your promised follow up diagnosis. Congrats on achieving a superb sub 3, showing a lot of grit and determination to achieve it. Guess there'll always be a drama when it comes to marathon running and you need to push through it



  • Registered Users Posts: 631 ✭✭✭Cleanman


    Congrats on a great race report Alan! Sorry you didn't get the time you wanted but between your training, positive mindset and determination, we all know you'll be back to smash through all time barriers soon. It's all about the journey :-)



  • Registered Users Posts: 752 ✭✭✭Back in Black


    As always a fantastic race report and huge kudos for finishing the marathon - that took massive mental strength so well done. As others have said someday soon it will all click and you will have a massive performance. Keep the faith!



  • Registered Users Posts: 3,182 ✭✭✭demfad


    "My ONLY motivation for doing Seville is to keep motivated over the winter and get some good sessions in - whatever time I run on the day will reflect that "

    Great race grit and great race report.

    You're plan for the winter was obviously a blinding success and I agree 100% on the focus on motivation to drive everything else.

    What will motivate you now?

    I have one short term tip (caveat, I haven't done this myself although the guy who told me is a very experienced marathoner/half marathoner etc.)

    You will be strong as the preverbial ox after recovering from this. As well as the big block in the bag you'll also have the marathon race itself. Due to the shoes you'll be recovered quicker and it wont lose as much fitness.

    The tip I got was that a PB or good time in a race like a HM (or 10 miler) is on the cards 5 weeks after a marathon.

    That might be good motivation for you for the next 4 weeks and it will mean you got a double use of that marathon block and will be in savage half shape with relatively little effort in 4 weeks. A good position to take into Spring/Summer.

    Anyway, great run, great entertaining read and chat soon hopefully!



  • Registered Users Posts: 4,807 ✭✭✭skyblue46


    Hey Alan, there was only one place that I was going to go first after ending my short Boards hiatus and you certainly haven't let me down. Another great effort from a young auld lad/auld young lad! I can only repeat what others have said, namely that it was a fantastic race report, a proper gritty race and a fantastic addition to your fitness bank. Congratulations 💪



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    Thanks folks - I've had a lot of time to drink & eat digest the race - my learnings are not rocket science and unfortunately have cropped up previously as 'learnings' that went un-acted upon.

    Here's my main takeaways - not in order of importance.

    To Paraphrase a certain Cork runner - Here's "10 Things I think About Marathon Training"

    (1) Longer steady efforts of MP or just slower would be better for me than doing MP intervals.

    5,4,3,2,1 MP - is quite an easier session than 15m@MP+20secs - / e.g. a session of WU/7m@MP+30 rolling into 8@MP/ CD would be better than a lot of my 'key' sessions.

    When I ran sub 3 at Dublin - I dont think I ran 1 effort at MP in a long run - a lot of longer Steady efforts.

    (2) Over distance efforts are required

    - I done 1 run of 2hr 50 - I need more an longer - even upto 25/26 miles.

    (3) Do more S&C

    I done NO S&C in the 16 week build up. I've NEVER done No S&C previously. - I need to keep the Pilates sessions going. I felt stronger with better form at Rotterdam - better able to handle the cramps.

    (4) Race day Mentality.

    After 30 mins on race day I was willing the end to come - I hadn't felt like that in any training session - I need to work on that (not quite sure how)

    (5) Surface Matters

    On Race day - I felt my Quads taking a hammering from the road surface quite early on - I hadn't really felt that running on tar paths, canal paths, cycle lanes etc. More efforts on Roads are needed to callous the legs e.g. When I didn't cramp in san seb - My 2 biggest runs were in Longwood 3/4 mara and DCM where I ran 22m of the race - both on Concrete Roads and both hilly steady efforts.

    (6) Pacing Matters

    I wanted to run the 1st 5k slower than the average - Failed.

    I also ran 5 quick miles (from mile 13 to 17 - slowest was 6.22) - Bad discipline.

    (7) Race day v Long Run Day.

    On Long run days I don't feel bloated, get up 3 hours before the race, fill myself full or Maurten drink the night before and morning of, I dont take beetroot juice 5 days prior, I don't take Precision hydration salt drinks with Sodium, Magnesium and Potassium.

    Either I repeat my race week protocol at least twice in advance or I take confidence to try my Long Run routine prior to race day.

    (8) Do More Hills at pace.

    I done very little hill work barring some slow recovery runs home. I know I should have done hill sprints to be able to recruit FT fibres, I know I should have done longer hills at pace to straighten the leg muscles.

    (9) The running community are fantastic - both virtually and in real life.

    (10) Follow a proper plan with appropriate periodisation - Dont pimp or makey up.


    And most of all - wear sunscreen...................



  • Advertisement


  • I wondered as well if the race you did was quite close to the marathon



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    I didn't race it, I ran it at MP. Part of a 20m session.





  • Fair enough.

    I think everyone could follow the points you made there anyway



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    I've so many questions and comments but don't want to turn it into pages of analysis. Lol. Might message offline.



  • Registered Users Posts: 361 ✭✭babacool


    I agree with all but no 3 mainly because I don’t really do s&c either but cover that part by plenty of hilly runs.


    no 4 I think I can help you there. Let me know if you are interested and we may be able to discuss on a run together.


    other than that great analysis and summary of key learnings.

    Post edited by babacool on


  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D


    Ah here. Keep it in the log. Isn’t that the point? (Or do both). 😁

    Post edited by Murph_D on


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 2,505 ✭✭✭Laineyfrecks


    Haha D, you read my mind🤣



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing




  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    OK fair enough...here goes....

    Anyone following this log over the past few months would've seen an exceptionally solid block of training. Was that your feeling too or did you have lingering doubts about producing a pb? If so it didn't come across in your log updates. That being said I know the marathon is an unpredictable beast .

    A lot of your learnings seem to suggest Daniels isn't necessarily right for you. Are you done with his marathon plans? I'm especially curious as to why you think longer steady runs are of more benefit than MP sessions. If I recall you had at least a 14 mile MP session.im struggling to see how a steady run at MP +30s is better than that.

    Why do you think over distance is important? I found this one really interesting. I know a few serious marathon guys, none of whom touch anywhere near 26 miles in training.

    I had no idea you were so disciplined pre big sessions. Is that always the case? Really made me rethink my own strategy which at best is average. Some of my big Monday sessions are often followed by a weekend of poor diet and too many drinks.

    Do you think you need hill sprints in the marathon block or should that be part of the base building pre marathon?

    Some of your learnings make me think coaching would be a better fit for you as none of the above are seen in most generic plans. Any plans to go back to coaching?

    I know you've probably analysed this to death but what was different about your San Seb block of training where you ran 2.52 with no cramping issues? There must be something different between now vs then?

    Last point and please don't take this the wrong way. I ask because I genuinely want to see you do well.

    In your learnings you don't mention anything about your paces in training. I've often noticed you run threshold or MP sessions either faster than prescribed or on the aggressive end of the range. Do you think that played any part in the legs maybe not being 100% conditioned? Or are you happy enough you're executing the sessions as you would like?

    I did warn ye! Take it as a compliment that I've thought this much about your success as a runner AMK. 🤣



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D


    Ha - this is more detailed than my wonderings (probably because Swashbuckler is in the middle of a marathon block and I am not) but it pre-empts pretty much all of my questions too. I especially would have asked the questions in the last paragraph - because they resonate with AMK's own thoughts from a few weeks before the race, a comment about marathon results being not as good as the training. Reading that I thought, if the result is disappointing (taking all factors into account, conditions on the day etc.), can the training really be thought of as 'better'?

    I do believe habitually exceeding goal effort in training is a problem - how can you get the adaptations you require if the appropriate stimulus is routinely exceeded? Especially over a gruelling marathon block. Isn't this a far more likely contributor to the cramping issue than anything else? Cramping seems to be a huge problem with marathon runners whose training is suboptimal - if it was happening to me regularly, I'd be asking questions about the training first, nutrition second. (Still good to ask questions about both, of course.)

    Also curious about over-distance runs. Seems to go against a good bit of the conventional wisdom these days - why?

    All this with the caveat that of course the marathon is a strange beast. Different day, different conditions, different course, things might have been very different, and all the post-race thinking would be different too. But looking my at own history (with admittedly much more modest abilities and ambitions) I would generally attribute a poor result to an overambitious target, or else a training approach that undermined an otherwise appropriately ambitious target - and I’ve been there a few times myself. I can be a slow learner.

    Ultimately, as most of us know from looking at people we know well, and whose training we can see every day, most of us, most of the time, get about the right result for what we put in.

    Post edited by Murph_D on


  • Registered Users Posts: 361 ✭✭babacool


    On the “working with a coach” section, I would phrase it slightly different: instead of following a generic plan (one not designed for a specific runner/target race), would you take the time and sit down look at another runner who received coaching in the lead up to a race and write down every session, every run including notes on paces, elevation etc and then follow that?


    with regards to longer runs, would you differ between: more time on feet during a long run that your actual race time on feet and distances covered? Personally I don’t think you need to run a marathon during training for a marathon but definitely should at least get close to the time on feet during the race. Though I can see the mental benefit of running longer during the training as long as it is slower too.


    as mentioned I do believe your cramping have a lot to do with your nutrition on the day. Overkill at least from own experience. Though SB I don’t see anything wrong in your lead up to a session. More the opposite, if you manage your tough sessions on a “weak” body race day should feel like a walk in the park (as you know I remain to be a firm believer in running on empty even if the run is late in the day!!!).


    Race pace vs Training pace, my question here would be what’s your thought process behind what route to take for a hard session? I have noticed that runners (I could myself doing that too a few times, won’t happen again) would pick a route with the mindset “here I will definitely be able to hit them paces. Not too much uphill, slightly downhill or flat and wind of almost no issue”. What’s your approach?


    The race itself, how do you approach that mentally? Do you look at it like “I’m going to run a marathon today!” Or more like “right, I break it down into 7 different, small races!” (Which I do to keep me mentally sharp throughout!). I usually come up with a good number of small targets that I want to accomplish in such a race and by that the first 30k fly by like it was nothing. 🙂



  • Registered Users Posts: 4,938 ✭✭✭squinn2912


    SB shout it out here I for one gain loads from the to and fro of all of you guys!



  • Registered Users Posts: 4,938 ✭✭✭squinn2912


    Wups sorry I should have been more patient and read the comments on!

    My little contribution is that it’s important to value the training that you’ve completed. Think about it as though it were someone else and what you would advise that person - I think you’d be like a lot of us and say Jaysus lad that was some training block. You might go as far as to say you did everything right, maybe you’d tell a fella to go and tweak some of the long runs or sessions. Sometimes we all dont have our day on the big day and it’s for reasons other than anything being ‘wrong’ in the build up preparations. You could have done that 10 different ways and in 3 of them cramped up, 3 of them been over or undercooked and 3 performed perfectly in accordance with your goals. That leave 1 for something mental to happen cos there’s always that possibility too.

    Anyhow I think you’re brilliant for offering up all of your thoughts and baring your training like this when things didn’t go your way… exactly. You showed some amazing toughness when the going wasn’t good and the chips were down. Well done!



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    Was that your feeling too or did you have lingering doubts about producing a pb? If so it didn't come across in your log updates. That being said I know the marathon is an unpredictable beast .

    Nope - I was very confident - even at 17-18 miles in - I was saying to myself, this will be my last Marathon - it'll be good to finish with a sub 2.50!


    A lot of your learnings seem to suggest Daniels isn't necessarily right for you. Are you done with his marathon plans? I'm especially curious as to why you think longer steady runs are of more benefit than MP sessions. If I recall you had at least a 14 mile MP session.im struggling to see how a steady run at MP +30s is better than that.

    I didn't follow Daniels :) - I followed a 2 Big Workout's a week strategy, the early part was Daniels, the later part was a mix n match.

    I had a straight 13.2 mile at Marathon effort in Donedea - that was the longest straight run. I'm not for 1 minute suggesting that all my runs should be longer runs at a straight MP+30 but they certainly have their place (every 2-3 weeks) as a support to the shorter MP (or faster) runs.

    My main point here is about my 'Big Sessions' - specifically the 5,4,3,2,1 - in a Marathon, you dont get a break (as you do in this session) - a better way of running this might be 1,2,3,4,5 - where the meat is at the latter end of the run, where you are tired.

    Or I could have just followed Daniels to the letter.


    Why do you think over distance is important? I found this one really interesting. I know a few serious marathon guys, none of whom touch anywhere near 26 miles in training.

    Over Distance should probably be 'Over Time' - While I might run 26 miles in the run up to a future Marathon - I wont go 27 or 28 miles.

    Theres a lot of people who do this - the NAZ Elite Plans have a 22/24/26 miler in them (they plan they sell to us mere mortals) - I do think it will help me with my cramping issue - If I hadn't a cramping issue - I wouldn't do it or recommend it.


    I had no idea you were so disciplined pre big sessions. Is that always the case? Really made me rethink my own strategy which at best is average. Some of my big Monday sessions are often followed by a weekend of poor diet and too many drinks.

    I'm not - I think you mis-read my point. I'm very disciplined in race week and not at all pre-session.

    a Bagel and 2 salt tabs and off I go on most sessions.


    Do you think you need hill sprints in the marathon block or should that be part of the base building pre marathon?

    Hill sprints being 10x12 seconds - its more of a technical session and can be done after an easy run - shouldn't cause any fatigue but these help with the FT/Intermediate Fibres - I would do them in the Marathon block going fwd.

    Some of your learnings make me think coaching would be a better fit for you as none of the above are seen in most generic plans. Any plans to go back to coaching?

    Nope - I don't have the psychology for it. "Run x miles at Y pace" would strike the fear pf Jebus into me and lead to a week of anxiousness.


    I know you've probably analysed this to death but what was different about your San Seb block of training where you ran 2.52 with no cramping issues? There must be something different between now vs then?

    I ran 2.58 in San Seb (No Cramp) and I ran 2.52 in Rotterdam.

    For Rotterdam - I was stronger and better able to manage the cramps - My pace didn't fall below 7 min/miles and I didn't stop.

    The Training was very similar for Rotterdam (2 big workouts) but this block was certainly superior in terms of the runs I done and the paces I ran.

    For Rotterdam I ran 26.3 miles (26.58 in Seville - despite following the line!!) The additional distance and the stop with 200m to go bugs me :)

    2.58 in San Seb (No Cramping) was done with a Pimped P&D schedule - I also ran 22m of DCM and also the 3/4 Marathon - both at steady paces.

    There was only really 1 workout midweek (Steve Way sessions) - with a long steady run at the weekend - with the exception of the 2 runs above and a HM in Athlone, all weekend runs were 7.30/7.40 pace which is MP+40 secs at best.

    Additional MLR's midweek also helped.

    Also in San Seb - I ran 26.2m


    In your learnings you don't mention anything about your paces in training. I've often noticed you run threshold or MP sessions either faster than prescribed or on the aggressive end of the range. Do you think that played any part in the legs maybe not being 100% conditioned? Or are you happy enough you're executing the sessions as you would like?

    Thats a fair take and something to take on board - as I was running MP Intervals, I was running them faster, often with a tail wind. I also wanted my training pace to be 6.20 and my race to be 6.25 as an insurance. I dont think 5 seconds is a big deal but I do know if I had of been running straight 15 milers at MP - it would have been closer to 6.30's.

    For the Tempos - I think I was running them fine (yep - maybe 5 secs faster) - but I was managing the 6-7 miles at Tempo pace, so I reckon if I was managing it, then it was grand. But certainly something to watch going fwd.

    The other thing was that for San Seb - I trained at slightly faster paces too - so I wanted to have that security.

    What would have made the legs more conditioned to run the marathon was longer runs at MP or slightly slower - no breaks.


    I did warn ye! Take it as a compliment that I've thought this much about your success as a runner AMK

    I do love a good analysis - its been a while



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    I do believe habitually exceeding goal effort in training is a problem - how can you get the adaptations you require if the appropriate stimulus is routinely exceeded? Especially over a gruelling marathon block. Isn't this a far more likely contributor to the cramping issue than anything else? Cramping seems to be a huge problem with marathon runners whose training is suboptimal - if it was happening to me regularly, I'd be asking questions about the training first, nutrition second. (Still good to ask questions about both, of course.)

    I am questioning my training. I don't think my training was 'sub optimal' - I think I chose the wrong strategy. Tergat/Tinman would have loved my training as it matches what he espouses. I need a new training strategy.

    My MP training paces were 5 seconds off as I outlined above (Intervals) I dont think this is a more likely contribution to my cramping.


    Also curious about over-distance runs. Seems to go against a good bit of the conventional wisdom these days - why?

    Explained above to Paul - there are a lot of plans and coaches who would recommend 26m runs and a lot that dont.

    Ultimately, as most of us know from looking at people we know well, and whose training we can see every day, most of us, most of the time, get about the right result for what we put in.

    I'm not quite sure if that is a general point or not??



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 1,238 ✭✭✭Wottle


    Hi AMK, maybe I missed it above but I think there's one other big factor that is out of your control that needs mentioning.

    Training at our lower temps 3°-10° and then racing between 10°-20° is a huge spanner in the works and I'd say the No1 reason for a slow down from mile 20.

    It's great you've got a few tweaks you can make but I wouldn't overthink them too much. Your block was brilliant and maybe Manchester would have been a better fit.

    Good read here from Alex Hutchinson, 7.5° being optimal for a marathon race, which was probably closer to our training temps.


    Post edited by Wottle on


  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    On the “working with a coach” section, I would phrase it slightly different: instead of following a generic plan (one not designed for a specific runner/target race), would you take the time and sit down look at another runner who received coaching in the lead up to a race and write down every session, every run including notes on paces, elevation etc and then follow that?

    You wouldn't believe how much I do that - but its dangerous to do that as well.


    with regards to longer runs, would you differ between: more time on feet during a long run that your actual race time on feet and distances covered? Personally I don’t think you need to run a marathon during training for a marathon but definitely should at least get close to the time on feet during the race. Though I can see the mental benefit of running longer during the training as long as it is slower too.

    I ran 2hr 50mins once in the build up - I'd do that more often and perhaps go further.

    as mentioned I do believe your cramping have a lot to do with your nutrition on the day. Overkill at least from own experience. Though SB I don’t see anything wrong in your lead up to a session. More the opposite, if you manage your tough sessions on a “weak” body race day should feel like a walk in the park (as you know I remain to be a firm believer in running on empty even if the run is late in the day!!!).

    Maybe it was overkill but it needed to be done to rule out 'stuff' - would I run a Marathon using the same stragety I use on a session day. No - I wouldn't have the confidence - what If I got Cramp :)

    Race pace vs Training pace, my question here would be what’s your thought process behind what route to take for a hard session? I have noticed that runners (I could myself doing that too a few times, won’t happen again) would pick a route with the mindset “here I will definitely be able to hit them paces. Not too much uphill, slightly downhill or flat and wind of almost no issue”. What’s your approach?

    My Tempos were on a 2m loop - so no issues there.

    My longer runs were typically done on the same route from Castleknock, down to the Canal, back into the park and home - again - I dont think this is an issue (maybe more on Roads v Tar)

    The race itself, how do you approach that mentally? Do you look at it like “I’m going to run a marathon today!” Or more like “right, I break it down into 7 different, small races!” (Which I do to keep me mentally sharp throughout!). I usually come up with a good number of small targets that I want to accomplish in such a race and by that the first 30k fly by like it was nothing. 

    I usually break it down into chunks - but didn't in Seville - no reason for it other than I didn't prepare for it like other races.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 220 ✭✭E.coli


    Always good to review what you do and try to adapt for next time but remember we can sometimes overcorrect to address the weaknesses and tend to ignore the things that worked for us so it is important to gain that perspective. You did a hell of a job aerobically and definitely a higher level of maturity to the log from past endeavors. There is an underlying confidence growing there to not have to prove you can hit paces but rather hit paces that are proven to get you the best bang for your buck.

    With that being said just a few thoughts from my end, like everyone this is just a few considerations it's by no means prescriptive

    1 - Steady vs MP.

    I would be of the same opinion as you I think you have done enough cycles of marathon to have the aerobic fitness to hit your paces. The sustained nature of those steadier ones I think suit a runner like you a bit better where you currently are. JD can build endurance quite successfully but I think a seasoned marathon runner can get some bang for the buck with regards the grit/psychological effect of longer sustained efforts

    2 - Overdistance

    Not a fan myself of this however there are some who swear by it. IIRC healy1835's friend/coach had a tasty 30 miler in the build up to his PB (believe Sean H did similar) when he was at his best

    3 - S & C

    Yes - I think this was something we touched on previously but go all in here. Not sure if you are still getting work done by KON but if you are ask her to have a look for potential anterior pelvic tilt. This can have a huge impact on tight quad muscles exacerbated by the nature of marathon running. Squats, Foam rolling and mobility and yoga to have the area with more lengthened muscles as well as strong

    4 - Plenty of hills

    Before you get into another marathon block take to the Magazine Fort/ Munich's for sessions. You have perfect training environment to address these area's. Tempos, Reps etc forget about time and just work on fatigue and strength that would stand to you hugely going into another block



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    Cheers for that AMK.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 10,512 ✭✭✭✭Murph_D


    Cheers A - and yes, that was meant to be a generalisation at the end. Not quite sure what you mean by the 'training strategy' point but I'm sure it will all become clear in time.



  • Registered Users Posts: 2,984 ✭✭✭Duanington


    Fair play for opening up to the floor on this one - it really should be the whole point of a log, or at least a lot of the reason behind having one.


    I couldn't agree more with the longer steady versus focusing so much on MP angle. Especially when you allow for how flexible you can make those runs, progression, alternating steady with MP etc....it allows for those huge aerobic gains but is that bit safer in terms of building up damage in the muscle fibres etc. I know I've bored the ears off you before about this but look up some Lydiard stuff for ideas on how to approach a block with that kind of strategy (Murph is a good reference point at the moment, he's putting it to good use)

    L mentions it above but I'd maximise the use of those hills in the park, forgetting about hitting a pace and just making sure you're working at the right level, the more I read and the more I listen to respected coaches or successful athletes, the more I look towards Howth for the next phase of training for me.

    I really think we have started to overcomplicate training with terminology and technology, especially us folks who are never going to make a dent at the pointy end of things. We don't HAVE to hit splits every single time, we don't HAVE to do anything more than look at how the fundamentals of most training plans originate from a very simple approach, run lots of miles, run easy miles very easy (which you do), run over lots of hills and develop aerobic strength by spending lots of time in that high end aerobic space but don't overcook it.


    You're a student of the sport so I've no doubt you'll find an interesting way forward, one last thing I would urge you to consider is to cast a conservative eye over your next plan.....rather than having so many big, knock it out of the park sessions and risk having to change them on the day because you're just not recovered enough (or whatever), maybe consider deliberately being conservative with some of the sessions when you're putting the plan together and avoid having to change them on the day. I really think this will serve you best in the long run. You most likely just don't need so many big sessions, you've had a super consistent few years.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 6,582 ✭✭✭Swashbuckler


    Great discussion going on here!

    On the hills L. I just zoned in on the way you said "before your next marathon block". That implies plenty of tempos and intervals in a phase of training building up to a marathon specific block right? With the actual marathon specific "block" I'd be interested to hear your thoughts on where hills fit in terms of the marathon specific/focussed sessions? Some discussions going on in other logs on this subject.



  • Registered Users, Registered Users 2 Posts: 5,236 ✭✭✭AuldManKing


    Thanks DD

    I spent a lot of time with the Jerry Kiernan group in Seville and a lot of here Marathoners follow a very simple style approach to training - maybe even conservative (certainly in regards to my approach)

    This will certainly be a feature in my next block as will the lumpy side of the park.

    Looking forward to it already!



  • Registered Users Posts: 2,984 ✭✭✭Duanington


    I work with a couple of folks from that group and I can recall seeing their marathon training for the first time while the rest of us slogged it out, I couldn't believe how conservative it was really. The proof of course, was in the results - which came in spades (one lad bypassed us all the year I ran Seville, having started at a very similar level, he finished the block with a 2.48 in Dublin)



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 361 ✭✭babacool



    I find this one interesting (posted it on a different thread too) and looking back at my lead up to the last 3 big races it’s been a similar approach/mindset by the coaches (I think).


    Apart from key workouts that were part of the long runs most of those been kept fairly short and always followed a workout day. Plus I personally think 2 20-22k runs a week each the day after a workout bring more to the plate than 1 22miler per week.


    All in all though I think we over complicate and over analyse things. Let’s just go out there and enjoy running. 🙂



Advertisement