What are your views on Multiculturalism in Ireland? - Threadbanned User List in OP

Very few people here even speak of conspiracies? None of the regular posters at least. So you want us to defend a position that we've never taken..... AGAIN?

Standard stuff from the script of the defenders and true believers of this politic. Avoid any relevant questions like the very plague because they quite simply can't answer them honestly as that would make for further uncomfortable questions, and answers. Instead paint(and believe) any that question this politic as bad actors, conspiracy nuts and racists. Which is so much easier to do of course. It's also an attempt to shut down any questions in the first place.

Look at Minister O'Brien's response last week to TD Nolan's relevant and "respectable" questions around housing and Ukrainian refugees. He accused her of "risking social cohesion" for even asking such questions. That there would be no cap and then the usual "we waz migrantz onze" rhetoric. Empty rhetoric because he didn't even outline any actual plan to deal with this, beyond "shure itll be grand". And I would ask the same minister; if the body of Irish society is so cohesive around this topic, why would such basic and pretty tame questions be risky?

By your own posts it does appear you wouldn't know an honest conversation if it was explained to you, in 10 metre high neon letters, with cheat codes. And this has been explained to you so many times, by so many people and yet you go right back to the same banal script, because you can't answer the basic questions you have no answers to.

Your laughably clumsy rhetorical "question", where the only "honest" answer you would accept is agreement with your rhetorical "question"? That one?

But for the craic, though it'll be of little benefit for actual debate as you've zero interest in that and will twist in the wind yet again to avoid any, I'll answer you directly. No. More than a few have stated quite clearly they don't buy into "replacement theories" BS, myself included. Many times in this thread people have stated quite clearly that "race" =/= culture, myself included. I've even given concrete examples where this is demonstrated. EG the Pakistani diaspora does worse in multicultural societies than the Indian disapora. Same "race". So I must be blaming religion then? Nope. The Malaysian diaspora also do better than the Pakistani diaspora. Same religion(for the most part). Culture clearly plays a part but it's not connected to "race". I don't even buy into the notion of race, because it's clumsy and simplistic, but rather look at shared genetic heritage which is far more accurate. EG the San peoples of southern Africa are "Black" but are more genetically distinct from other "Black" peoples living in the same areas as a Swede and a Saudi Arabian.

But as I said you wouldn't know an honest conversation on this topic if you tried. And you're clearly not interested in trying.

The "unknown question(s)". OK then, honest Abe, answer this one, one that has been repeatedly asked of you and your position: Name one "multicultural" Western nation where the exact same trends don't play out along the same demographics. Point me to one "multicultural" Western nation where those of African origin don't tend to cluster at the bottom regarding education, employment, poverty. Point me to one "multicultural" Western nation with all their different histories, politics and policies who got it right. You've a lot of choices to pick from, so answer that direct question please.

That's too much for you? OK, then answer me this one; why is diversity only an apparent strength to "multicultural" White Western nations? Surely if this diversity is such a boon we should be exporting the concept to non White Western nations?