WW Christmas: Naughty or Nice GAME Thread

I don't know if wolf lorcan kills duffman. They'd finally won them over with the nothing argument yesterday, so it is not like they were still at loggerheads.

Going back to the lynches, my original thought was no wolves on Cup in day 1. That to me anyway has now been proved right, althought i thought i was wrong with nothing. My second gut feeling was that a wolf voted for neo in the second lynch. That would leave me with either Baggly or kitten. Now of the two of them, I'm not sure but kitten's reasoning hasn't been top notch today if you ask me. An experienced player doesn't seem to me to be the strongest reason and even earlier agreed with the idea of policy lynching lorcan. That seems like a great plan for a wolf. Get someone lynched and go down to the final three and hope for the best.

Lynch #1

Cup (5) - Green and red, nothing, leg end reject, duffman, Barney92 

StrawbsM (2) - kitten_k, Aisling

All others have one;

Hello2DPersonBelow (1) - StrawbsM

Baggy (1) - JP Liz v1

Kitten_K (1) - Lorcan 

JP Liz v1 (1) - Baggy

Neowise (1) - Yoss 

Lorcand (1) - Neowise

Leg end reject (1) - Cup

Nothing (1) - Echoplasm

Cup has been lynched

Lynch 2

Neowise (6) - Baggly, Leg end reject, lorcand, kitten_k, yoss, duffman

Lorcand (2) - nothing, Neowise 

Nothing (1) - Aisling 

Duffman (1) - JP Liz v1

Did not vote - Barney92

Neither of you!

Who would you have voted for last night Barney?

Also lorcan is accidentally scratched off there in the day 2 votes.

Ok that's fair I'm just trying to work some things out, don't think I've cleared you though 😋

What about Kitten?

Duffman was targeted for munch twice though - its possible the wolf knew they were BG for the second one - but i havent seen anything that hinted at Duffman being BG before the failed munch. On that basis the wolf munched into the wagon before they knew who Duffman was.

Duffman was targeted twice? How do you know that? Or have I missed something?

Although I suppose the logic kinda adds up that the wolf would target the same player twice. But how could you be sure

If you were Mrs Clause who would you protect first in the game? I'd wager yourself. Perhaps they found Santa before their first protection and then protected Santa first, then themselves day 2 (stopped the munch) and then munched the next time because they were going to be unprotected. However, that does not mean that duffman was definitely munched twice.

There was a failed munch on him and then a successful munch on him?

Well there was a failed munch on someone and then a munch on duffman. Likely it was two hits on duffman but it was the certainty in your statement that stood out to me.

Himself not myself

Im certain in retrospect. Duffman was BG and BG always protect themselves on odd numbered days, unless there is an outed role they need to protect.

Slip? :D

Joking im sticking with outside the wagon.