Looking to buy, 20k budget

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 11:38am #1

This is probably a question that has been asked before but I couldn't find it in the forum. We're a two car household and the time has come to replace our second car which after 16 years of ownership owes us nothing.

The second car is used mainly by my wife as a run about and wouldn't usually do more than about 40-50KMs a day at most. It gets the odd trip farther than that, but very rarely. It's mostly used for a short work commute and ferrying our two kids around. Obviously we're a prime candidate for an EV.

We have a 20K budget and from what I can tell that puts the 40KW Leaf, 28KW Ioniq and the i3 in range. While I love the i3 and would buy it in the morning, my wife hates it and so it's been ruled out 🙄 Personally I think the other two are a bit 'meh' and don't particularly like either of them.

My wife really likes the leaf and it appears that you get a bit more for your money with the leaf. Her only real stipulation is that she wants heated seats and would like to be able to warm the car up before leaving on a cold morning. My fear with the leaf is trying to hold on to a bit of future re-sale value. The plan is to probably not hold on to it as long as our last car. The leaf uses the chademo charging system and while nearly all of our charging will be done at home that might not be the case for a potential future owner who might need to rely more on public charging. I think any future development of the public charging network is likely to be CCS only and so I think the leaf is likely to become a less attractive option in the future.

So, my question is what would you do? Buy a leaf or a slightly older Ioniq? Or is there a third option I'm missing?

Water John · 05-04-2023 11:40am

You don't mention the other car. Should that be the EV?

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 11:46am

Sorry. We currently have a Mercedes c350e which is the primary family car and which we're keeping for the time being. The car we are replacing is 2001 Toyota Yaris as it's getting harder and more costly to put it through the NCT each year.

SteM · 05-04-2023 11:48am

If your mileage is really only 40-50KMs a day at most I'd be buying a 24 kWh Leaf and banking what you save. They're ideal second cars imho.

Water John · 05-04-2023 11:51am

Sorry, wasn't prying, but sometimes with the range of EVs now, the reverse should sometimes be considered. I understand.

creedp · 05-04-2023 11:57am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443155#Comment_120443155

Agree if only to be used as a local runaround buy the cheap leaf and not worry about resale value or future proofing fast charging

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 11:59am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443155#Comment_120443155

Financially that makes the most sense but I really really can't stand the looks of the older leaf. I know that people will think I'm stupid for letting that be a factor in my decision but unfortunately these things factor for me when buying a car

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 12:01pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443170#Comment_120443170

No worries. These are things to consider alright

Water John · 05-04-2023 12:05pm

So it's a Kona or Ioniiq. Even though I drive a Leaf, I would swap readily for the Kona my wife drives.

Other lad and lassies here would know more but getting something like a Zappi charger could link into future PV panels, esp if it's parked at home sometimes during the day.

creedp · 05-04-2023 12:12pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443197#Comment_120443197

It's hardly surprising that people want to buy a car that they like the look of. Agree the 1st gen leaf is a marmite car. If you can overcome the looks its a fine car once you're comfortable with its limitations. Personally I don't like the look of the 2nd gen leaf, either inside or out, but it's a more capable car if you can get it at a decent price. I was in a garage recently that had a 2018 leaf with over 100k km for €28k. I'm hoping somebody doesn't buy it at anywhere near that price!

Soarer · 05-04-2023 12:14pm

Just went through exactly the same situation as you.

Roughly same budget, same cars to choose from.

Love the i3, but not practical for kids jumping in and out, having to open the front door(s) to let the lads out of the back, etc.

Had a Leaf before and love them. Was gonna go for a 30kWh Tekna, but like you, the reservations about Chademo and resale values came to the fore.

So I’m after buying a 28kWh Ioniq. Haven’t picked it up yet (tomorrow) and have never sat in one before let alone driven one! But I know all about them and their benefits, so decided it was the “safest” option.

Best of luck with your decision.

Buddy Bubs · 05-04-2023 12:14pm

Ioniq 28 mentioned in your OP seems to be very well thought of on this forum by owners and previous owners. If my budget was sub 20k that's where I'd be looking all day.

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 12:31pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443228#Comment_120443228

PV is definitely in our future so that's food for thought. 👍

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 12:34pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443265#Comment_120443265

I think that's crazy money alright! I'm not overly gone on the looks of the second gen leaf either but i do think it's a big improvement on the 1st gen which makes it more palatable.

Inconspicuous · 05-04-2023 12:40pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443277#Comment_120443277

Congrats on the new purchase. I've taken the Ioniq out for a spin and except for finding the steering to be a bit light it's a grand car. I reckon I'll be doing the same as you and looking for 28kw model.

Quick question on the Ioniq if you don't mind, can the car be preheated through and app and are their heated seats as standard?

ELM327 · 05-04-2023 12:45pm

Buy the ioniq28. I've had two and sold both to boardsies!

You get heated seats and steering wheel as standard, there's no app though but they heat up super quick. Much better than the leaf equivalent where you need SVE spec to be sure of heated seats and steering wheel, and they take ages to heat up and then seem to go on and off a bit rather than maintain constant heat. I had one leaf, an SVE. The ioniq is a much better car for the money. There was one for sale here recently for 15k

Soarer · 05-04-2023 12:48pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443385#Comment_120443385

Thanks! And they’re the same sort of questions I had!

There’s no app, which is a balls. Car can be preheated, but it has to be scheduled in the car beforehand. By all accounts, the Ioniq heats up extremely fast.

That’s one of the pluses of the Leaf. But everything else, including 6.6kW AC charging as standard, the Ioniq wins.

I hope anyway!

Water John · 05-04-2023 1:24pm

Might look at trading up myself. Have a 30kw Leaf 161. I'd want more range on the next purchase.

unkel · 05-04-2023 3:01pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058291181/what-would-you-do

As a former Ioniq owner I have to highly recommend it too. And can I compliment you on your first post? You had already very extensively done your research before asking questions here.

There are also a few other choices you mightn't have considered. An e-Golf and even a brand new MG4

eagerv · 05-04-2023 3:06pm

I think in your position I would also look (again😊) at the Ioniq 28. But try and get as late as possible, cant remember but was it 2019? Alternatively the 38kWh version if you don't need to fast charge often. I am sure with your bargaining skills you may be able to be within or close to budget...😁

kai57 · 05-04-2023 3:43pm

Buy another Yaris!

unkel · 05-04-2023 3:54pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120444258#Comment_120444258

If only Toyota sold an electric one. For around the €20k mark. Then the OP probably would. Unfortunately Toyota has chosen to be like Kodak, so it seems.

Welcome to boards anyway, interesting first post 😁

Girl Geraldine · 05-04-2023 4:11pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120443147#Comment_120443147

I always laugh when this sort of line comes out. How in the name of jesus fúck , when whole costs are broken down to an annual figure, could a new EV be cheaper to run than an old but well maintained Yaris. The capital repayments on an EV are huge, whereas the Yaris is paid for years ago.

And the thing with EVs is the battery technology could change in the blink of an eye meaning all of a sudden the value of your 1 or 2 year old car nosedives the demand will be for the new tech long range fast charge cars, and what you have no-one will want.

it is not a mature technology and it is unwise to take the chance unless you like to see the value of your investment evaporate over night.

eagerv · 05-04-2023 4:13pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120444258#Comment_120444258

A lot to be said for one.

We still have a 1999 one in the family. Belonged originally to my mother, then went to my wife. The kids learn to drive on it and was used for years as a general hack in the family. Now has gone to my elderly father in law who loves the simplicity, slightly higher driving position and all around visibility. Apart from a good few 12v batteries, nothing serious has ever gone wrong. Still feels fresh inside and tight to drive, pity the outside not quite as good..😊

TMY · 05-04-2023 4:21pm

Would an egolf be out of the question? Lovely car and likely to be a few bargains out there with people trading up to id4's. A few examples on carzone are within budget and the range would be adequate.

Girl Geraldine · 05-04-2023 4:25pm

eGolfs are an experimental ball of shíte. Stay away from those, they are worth nothing.

They can't be fixed once they give trouble. From what I heard, a lot of spare parts aren't and never even were available and there are no technical manuals for them available to dealers from VW.

slave1 · 05-04-2023 4:35pm

Drive a 30kWh Leaf and Ioniq, the Leaf is uber comfy and remote app to warm the car up which cannot be underestimated

joe1303l · 05-04-2023 5:35pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120444403#Comment_120444403

Really ?? Have you had one in the past that couldn’t be fixed ?

unkel · 05-04-2023 7:15pm

@Girl Geraldine - "when whole costs are broken down to an annual figure, could a new EV be cheaper to run than an old but well maintained Yaris. The capital repayments on an EV are huge, whereas the Yaris is paid for years ago."

Classic misconception. Capital repayments are not costs. Depreciation and interest are, so are opportunity costs. But not repayments.

crl84 · 05-04-2023 8:39pm

If it was me, given the scenario and budget you've outlined, I'd probably go for a PHEV tbh

Buddy Bubs · 05-04-2023 9:56pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/120444360#Comment_120444360

You are right about the cost effectiveness of an old yaris v a new Ev, cant argue there. But......When these long range fast charging EVs come out, and I've no doubt the ranges and charging speeds will improve over time, they will cost a fortune. Manufacturers aren't going to give them away for free or even same price as current tech cars. I'd be fairly confident my 350+km EV that I drove Dublin to mayo and back at the weekend with a 30 min stop on each leg will still be valued in a few years.

Looking to buy, 20k budget

Comments