Advertisement
If you have a new account but are having problems posting or verifying your account, please email us on hello@boards.ie for help. Thanks :)
Hello all! Please ensure that you are posting a new thread or question in the appropriate forum. The Feedback forum is overwhelmed with questions that are having to be moved elsewhere. If you need help to verify your account contact hello@boards.ie

Domestic Solar PV Quotes 2022 - No PM requests - See Mod note post #1

Options
1195196197199201

Comments

  • Registered Users Posts: 1,454 ✭✭✭DC999


    You're better off doing more frequent shorter EV charges if it won't all fit in the cheap night rate. If it's a Zappi there is an option to add X kWh's per day.



  • Registered Users Posts: 20,055 ✭✭✭✭Cyrus


    the charger is set to only charge during the night rate window so if it needs a top up the next evening it gets it.



  • Registered Users Posts: 3 Boots87


    Hi All,

    Please help. I have spent way too long mulling over all of this so I pray someone can help me. My motivation is to try and become as self sufficient as possible - i want to make the world a small bit better if possible for my kids and save a few bob would be nice too.

    I currently have 4 solar panels which were installed on my new build house in 2018. My PV meter in my fuseboard has recorded approx 900kw/h in a calendar year. No fancy app to get a good understanding of what exactly I am getting from these solar panels. I have imported about 3300kw/h since September 2022 via display on my actual smart meter itself.

    I have analysed my data via esb account and can see my average daily usage since June 2023 on this dashboard to now is around 7.5kw. I am exporting back a fair bit and since june 22nd to 31st october generated approx 160kwh which I will be credited for via FIT. Basically I find my setup pretty good but as mentioned above its difficult to determine an accurate reflection of my average daily consumption as the esb app just shows what I import and export, there is no way to really know how much energy I obtain via my panels before the grid kicks in. This has really fired my brain for ages trying to understand this

    I am putting my annual usage around 3700kwh mark

    I have considered adding new efficient panels and have been quoted for 14 including battery 9k after grant. I read that its a good idea to fill the roof. I am east west so splitting it might be a good option. I have no EV and wife not onboard about switching to one anytime soon. I work from home 3 days and always someone home (grandparents minding 2 kids).

    Based on the above is 5.6kwp a good choice or too much? What is meant by the expected annual yield? Should I defer battery for now/add more less panels? Should I stay as I am (0.33 import rate now, €450 Gov credits due, 0.21 FIT)? Finally EDDI sounds appealing but in summer would the water be hot at 7am?

    I guess my usage will go up as kids get bigger and im hopeful EVs will become the norm. I like the idea of a nice app to manage all of this. I may be a little over specced on 14 panels and id probably rule out the battery at least for the first while. East West config would possibly work well giving me juice in the morning and evening to coincide with my peaks.

    However, my hunch is that its probably best option for me to stay as I am for now and obtain more data but looking forward to some feedback. These grant changes and salesmen have me under pressure 😂



  • Registered Users Posts: 99 ✭✭Alan McG


    Nobody ever complained about having put too much soar PV on the roof - Max it out.

    You're somewhat right about the battery - it doesn't offer as much value now that export is so good. However this assumes a flat 24h rate. If you switch to a Night meter, or a time of use tariff then this isn't as true. And exporting electricity during the day actually makes more financial sense than using it yourself.

    To get a balance between "self-sufficiency" (which I don't actually believe is possible in Ireland with PV) and cost you might consider installing a ~7.5Kwh battery and charging it up over night at the cheap rate. This will cover your normal day use. Initially, I went with a small Pylontech battery, which is pretty basic, but it meant that I could add further batteries myself as my family’s usage changed & costs reduced. If I went with some of the more expensive "fancier" batteries I would have needed to get an installer in each time, vastly increasing the cost.

    With the move to everything electric you'll definitely get the use & payback from this setup over the coming years, and you might as well strike while the grant iron is hot!



  • Registered Users Posts: 20,055 ✭✭✭✭Cyrus


    Hi Folks


    just got this quote, main thing im wondering about is the invertor if i want to add a battery in the future, is this a good one?

    4.35 kw system

    10 x 435w Jinko N type black panels

    Sofar inverter (3K...6KTLM-G3)

    Fire shunt isolator

    Van Der Valk roofing system

    AC And DC cabling

    Associated MCB board works

    System app monitor for phone

    Ber certificate



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 238 ✭✭AmpMan




  • Registered Users Posts: 824 ✭✭✭HotSwap


    Not true. You can have as many panels as you want by planning law and the only thing ESB care about is the export capacity of your inverter.



  • Registered Users Posts: 6,719 ✭✭✭deezell


    So the limit is 5 kw export. This implies the maximum input of the inverter in terms of voltage and current. Too many panels and you are in danger of breaching the maximum input no load voltage. Choice of panels will optimise this. Hybrid inverters generally can output greater than 5kw, 5 to grid and maybe 2 to battery. If you want to output max to grid and additional to home consumption, you can spilt your home circuits into on and off grid. (a trivial job at the consumer unit). You can then buy an inverter with and off grid branches, such as the Sungrow, or install an extra low cost non hybrid. One on grid and one off, panels spilt between them. Off grid would give power backup during a failure from panels, from the battery if it was hybrid. I'd imagine you'd be fleeced by installers for this second option though, even if it only involves maybe a €500 extra unit.



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,454 ✭✭✭DC999


    As a fellow procrastinator, get quotes. You have enough data. And I say that kindly :)

    East / West is a common setup and works well. What I have. Produces maybe 80% of a South setup.

    Ignore Eddi. Export rate is 20C plus for unused units. Heat immersion on cheap night rate instead and export what Eddi would of used.

    Max out what the roof and budget can take as others have said



  • Registered Users Posts: 3 Boots87


    Thanks DC999. I am chipping away at getting my quote in line with the 1.2 by KwP which I found on here. Boards has been so useful plenty of great info around



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 19,654 ✭✭✭✭Muahahaha


    Wondering what others think of this quote. Ive been trying to hit the 1,200 per kwp benchmark but after almost 10 quotes over the last 6 months have not been able to find a company at this rate. It is probably because my system is limited by a small roof which has a velux window thus reducing the size of the solar array.

    Anyway quote includes a hybrid inverter & an Eddi. It is either 7 Jolywood panels of 415k watts for e4,700 (net of grant) or if possible 8 panels for 5,000 euro. So its going to be either a 2.9kwp or a 3.3kwp system. So 7 panels would work out at 1,620 per kwp and 8 panels at 1,515 per kwp.

    Im under a bit of pressure as the grant is reducing by 300 in January and the company can get the paperwork in before Xmas to avoid the decrease. So need to make a decision in by next week.

    Couple of questions- when people talk of the benchmark of 1,200 per 1kwp is that calculation not including the Eddi? And any feedback on these Jolywood panels and 3kw Suzhou Hypontech string inverter, have never heard of them as most companies seem to use Jinko panlels and unsure of if a 3kw inverter is big enough or what limitations it has. And would also welcome comments on paying about 1,600 per kwp. Should I just truck on and suck up the 300 euro decrease in the grant to try to find a company at 1,200 per 1kwp. Or is my small roof and system forever going to mean I cant hit that benchmark? Because thats what it kind of feels like after lots of quotes way above it.

    Post edited by Muahahaha on


  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 6,087 Mod ✭✭✭✭graememk


    The 1.2k is including grant but not eddi or the extra for a hybrid inverter.

    With smaller systems it's hard to get down to that figure.

    I'd personally ditch the eddi as the feed in is so good



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,454 ✭✭✭DC999


    I paid €1600/kWh 18 months ago. Mine is a small house so they put panels on 4 different sections of roof. So took way more labour. I’m still delighted to have solar.

    You’re paying more than the rule of thumb as it’s a small system and labour costs are largely the same if they mount 20 panels our 8. Plus as you’ve gotten 10 quotes, the costs are what the market can charge at the moment.

    A 3kWp system is very small. I’d suggest get the largest the roof and budget can take. EVs, electric heating….mean our houses will consume more electricity in the future.

    A 3kW inverter is plenty for 8x415w panels. Most inverters can be oversized by close to 50% of panels. The installer can check the max limit.

    Drop the Eddi as others have said. FIT is paying 20c plus for an unused kWh sent back to the grid. Then just pull the trigger and book it in. 



  • Registered Users Posts: 19,654 ✭✭✭✭Muahahaha


    Thanks for this. Yeah I think I have to accept Im not going to find a quote at the 1,200 per 1kwp benchmark as it is such a small system.

    Just on the Eddi though, if Im paying 33c per kwh from Energia and they are only giving 20c FiT does it not make more sense to heat the water using solar power rather than using power at 33c per kwh?



  • Moderators, Home & Garden Moderators Posts: 6,087 Mod ✭✭✭✭graememk


    How do you currently heat your water?

    Oil? Gas? Immersion?

    Oil/gas cost could be in the 10-15c/kWh range.

    Electric(immersion), well ideally you would do the bulk of your heating on night rate.

    Back to oil/gas, the eddi is only replacing the cost of that say 15c. And it costs 500. That's 3333kwh you need to put through the eddi before you actually save any money.

    If you exported the same amount at 20c, that. Would be worth €666...

    Eddi is a convenience option. Not an economic one. As long as you know that work away.



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,757 ✭✭✭funnyname


    We use 11k units pa, looking to offset this with a solar pv install, currently no EV but hope to have one in the next year or so. We have 3 roofs available for panels, house south and west facing, garage (ac connection to the house) south facing.

    House was surveyed yesterday, asked them to maximise the system so as to future proof it.

    Got a quote this morning of €17.3k net of grant, I think it looks very good, any comments?

    34 panels (430w), 5kw hybrid inverter in house, 5kwh battery in house and 5kw inverter in garage.

    H south - 17 panels

    H west - 7 panels

    G south - 10 panels



  • Registered Users Posts: 33 nickibopp


    At the end of a frustrating year I'm desperate for a bit of advice please. Paid a hefty €5k deposit back in August on an 11 panels array with a Livoltek hybrid Inverter (incl 5.12K battery) producing 4143kwh/a (€13,300 before SEAI grant, €10,900 net) based on the solar company's assurance that in addition to the 5 panels on my roof (which they installed in August and are sitting there doing nothing) the further 6 panels could be installed using a cherry picker on the gable end of the house (east-facing, the roof faces South). The company then decided it wasn't safe to use a cherry picker due to power lines overhead and told me to get my ground level Lean-to roof reinforced so they could climb up on it and install on the gable from there. In the midst of lots of other work what was causing lots of other trouble we couldn't get anyone to do the lean-to roof job.

    The solar company says at last that their roofers will do this reinforcement ("only 2 hrs work" they keep saying) and I am trying to agree that they pay the labour and I'll pay the materials as I have no need of a reinforced roof only for them to finish the job they started. I have also asked them to give me a discount for the electricity I should have generated.

    They have now come back with a revised proposal with a change in hardware and I am concerned that they might be cutting corners to recoup their costs at my expense. They are offering €320 off the invoice towards electricity not generated, and €250 off for a hot water diverter that I didn't need, which seems fair and any reduction is welcome. But the spec has changed from a Livoltek inverter (not apparently on the SEAI EEE list so maybe that was a lucky escape) to a Solis 1p5k-4g.

    This is the proposal:

    11 x RSM130-8-440M 440 Watt Panels (Risen Energy Co., Ltd.)

    1 x Solis-1P5K-4G (SOLIS - Ningbo Ginlong Technologies)

    1 x BX51100 (Dyness)

    Standard System Price

    €13,300.00


    Any thoughts would be well appreciated. I really liked the company and probably could have shopped around more but they were local and really helpful - there has been a lot of personnel change while I've been dealing with them, though, and I have lost quite a bit of faith in them. But with my deposit paid I feel a bit backed into a corner.


    Thanks...

    Post edited by nickibopp on


  • Registered Users Posts: 19,654 ✭✭✭✭Muahahaha


    Thanks for this, At the moment I heat water using a night rate of 14c/kwh. So I suppose with that in mind it makes financial sense to not get the Eddi and continue to heat water overnight at 14c a unit and for any excess solar power during the day to be sold back to the grid at 20c a unit.



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,493 ✭✭✭Cole


    Hi everyone,

    Any opinions on this quote?

    • 10 x Jinko Tiger 435 N-Type (JKM435N-54HL4R-B) 435 Watt Panels (Jinko Solar)
    • 1 x Solis H1 Energy Storage 3.6kW Hybrid 5G Inverter with DC switch (Solis)
    • 1 x Dyness 5.1 kWh Battery (DL5.0C)
    • 1 x FSS
    • 1 x Eddi with Hub
    • 1 x BER
      • €11,321.00

    Many thanks for any views...all very new to this!



  • Registered Users Posts: 788 ✭✭✭staples7


    No offence but you sound painful to deal with, the power lines are not the installers problem, nor is the roof that cannot support them. If my installers turn around to me next week and tell me they can't install due to factors connected with house or surroundings. Im not going to ask them to pay the labour associated with extra work for them to get up there.


    I think the installers made a mistake by half doing it, they should have just walked and given your deposit back. Your now looking for lost electricity 😳😳



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 1,454 ✭✭✭DC999


    Woah! That's 14.6kWp of panels but the ESB limit is a little over 5kW of an inverter in total. That means the system can't produce more than 5kW. You can oversize to around 8kWp on a 5kW inverter depending on the design and roof orientation. But nothing like 14.6kWp.

    Unless you already have 3 phase you can't go that large. What was their rationale for such a large system?

    Or to get above the 5kW limit, you need to pay the ESB 1k for an 'NC7' so you've a large connection from the house. But that's not non refundable AFAIK and can be more costs on top of that to EBS.

    Looks like they are providing 2 x 5kW inverters. Once the 5kWh battery is filled (which will really really early in the morning based on your system size), then 2nd inverter won't be doing anything.

    Btw, it you're using 11000kWh a year, it's 30kWh a day average without an EV. You've a heatpump I guess, yeah? So in winter it's more likely 50+kWh a day and much lower in summer. A 5kWh battery won't touch the sides of such a heavy winter usage - mentioning in case you're not aware.



  • Registered Users Posts: 33 nickibopp


    Thanks, you're probably right, point taken.



  • Registered Users Posts: 4,765 ✭✭✭ablelocks


    got a top level quote for huawei system - 22 panels, 10kw battery, (no eddi needed have solar tubes for hotwater apr to sept and oil-fired when needed))

    circa 14k (not incl grant) - does that sound ok?



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,064 ✭✭✭Comer1




  • Registered Users Posts: 33 nickibopp


    Thanks, you're right I am thinking and overthinking and stressed beyond sense. You did misunderstand me though for the record - the roof supporting the panels isnt the issue (house roof is already full owith 5 panels) , the other 6 panels are going on a wall and that roof in question is a plastic roof over my washing line that is now required to support workers to work from while installing onto the wall. I'm worried about damage to the plastic roof, risk to the workers, you name it, I've lain awake freaking out about it. And of course the colossal cost that I fear is an unwise investment. You're right, I'm lucky they put up with me, thanks for the perspective, i needed to hear it.



  • Registered Users Posts: 797 ✭✭✭tonysopprano


    If you can do the job, do it. If you can't do the job, just teach it. If you really suck at it, just become a union executive or politician.



  • Registered Users Posts: 6,404 ✭✭✭con747


    Interesting, because even at €15500.00 it says the below


    Post edited by Boards.ie: Mike on

    Don't expect anything from life, just be grateful to be alive.



  • Registered Users Posts: 1,493 ✭✭✭Cole




  • Registered Users Posts: 797 ✭✭✭tonysopprano


    If you can do the job, do it. If you can't do the job, just teach it. If you really suck at it, just become a union executive or politician.



  • Advertisement
  • Registered Users Posts: 6,719 ✭✭✭deezell


    I tend to agree, It's a simple three rule decision tree, it's no HAL. Users shouldn't infer any intelligence or intuitive process to it just because the decision process is not obvious from the advice given, though there is an attempt to flesh out decisions in the notes.

    The entire rule base is as follows, based on the price to you after Grant, BER, Eddie. If you're not entitled to a Grant, the decision is still based on the Kwp price calcuated less the appropriate grant

    1. Kwp<=€1150 then "Go for it,"

    2. €1150 <Kwp<=€1300 then " Get more quotes"

    3. Kwp>1300 then "Look elsewhere"

    A similar rule set is applied to where 'Batteries are Included'. So in this calculator world a 5Kwp system is ideally €5000 to you (after €2400 grant, (total €7400). "Go for it" up to €5750, "Get more quotes" €5751 to €6500,"Look elsewhere" from €6501 onwards. The very basics of ChatGPT reasoning, and all AI for that matter.

    Post edited by Boards.ie: Mike on


This discussion has been closed.
Advertisement