Joe Brolly calls JP McManus out over GAA donations

mountai · 17-12-2023 12:36pm #1

Article in todays Independent , Joe Brolly calls out JPs donations to GAA for what they are . Discuss .

NIMAN · 17-12-2023 12:38pm

Haven't read it, behind a pay wall.

Can you tell us what he said?

F1ngers · 17-12-2023 12:40pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058327259/joe-calls-jp-out

What's your opinion?

Gregor Samsa · 17-12-2023 12:40pm

Discuss

No.

how about:

A link to the article
A sumnary of the points raised
Some of your own opinions on the matter to kick things off.

Cetyl Palmitate · 17-12-2023 12:49pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121505558#Comment_121505558

"Behind a paywall"!? The Sunday independent has been "behind a paywall" since it's formation. The paywall is it's entire business model!

magicbastarder · 17-12-2023 12:55pm

There's already at least one thread about this topic anyway. I hardly think JB's contribution will be so stellar as to have changed the issue enough to warrant a new thread.

Bobson Dugnutt · 17-12-2023 1:10pm

Read it this morning. Brolly has a point but his writing style is terribly constipated.

Hank the DJ · 17-12-2023 1:19pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058327259/joe-calls-jp-out

What are they?

Jack Daw · 17-12-2023 4:04pm

Everything Joe Brolly says should be ignored. The fact he's a popular figure in Irish media is baffling to me, I've always been immune to his perceived charms.

JP McManus could easily live as he is and not donate a penny to any organisation in Ireland, with the way the laws are he owes this country absolutely nothing.Also Ireland is itself a tax haven for companies so we can't exactly be getting all huffy if some of our own citizens decide to live in tax havens. At least he's actually contributed something to the country over the years, I'm sure their are plenty of other wealthy Irish citizens who contribute zero to this country either through tax or philanthropy.

knockoutned · 17-12-2023 4:06pm

You would think that on the online version they would have redacted the bank account information in the picture. I am sure JP is questioning his decision on giving Roscommon money.

StupidLikeAFox · 17-12-2023 4:45pm

Joe Brolly's sole purpose in life is to dream up the hottest of hot takes for any given situation. He's constantly looking for a different angle, typically the most self righteous one at that.

JPs tax status is either may bother you or it might not - either way it's completely separate and irrelevant to this donation, which was very generous regardless of his tax status or how much money he has in his bank account.

coolshannagh28 · 17-12-2023 4:48pm

Haven't read the article but I'm sure Joe discusses JP's tax affairs however another factor is JP has poured millions into Limerick GAA skewing the field which has been fairly criticised; now he throws a bun to every other county...why ? So he can feel better about it ?

Whats to stop some other multibillionaire throwing millions at his pet county ...and where does this leave the alleged amateur status of the organisation?

Ten of Swords · 17-12-2023 4:58pm

Discuss.

1) Didn't provide a link

2) Article is paywalled

3) Didn't offer any opinion

Are you trying to get banned?

cnoc · 17-12-2023 5:10pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506410#Comment_121506410

Deleted wrong thread.

Jack Daw · 17-12-2023 6:28pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506410#Comment_121506410

If rich people want to help out their counties then fair play to them.He's been pumping money into Limerick GAA for donkey's years and it's only having a big impact now so it isn't exactly a quick fix Man City/Chelsea/PSG type solution, All of Limerick's players are from Limerick itself they're not paying for players from Cork and Tipp to come play for them.

They've managed to revive a county which was a complete basket case for a large period of time and where the county team were a complete shambles at the start of the 2010's.The revival of Limerick into a big hurling force has been great for the sport as it's certainly better than the traditional big 3 dominating all the time and itls good to see the sport thriving in one of the countries biggest cities where it looked in the past to be dieing and falling in popularity due to the popularity of Munster's rugby team.If his money has helped boost the sport in Limerick and get more kids interested in GAA then that can only be good for the sport.

geographica · 17-12-2023 6:32pm

Will the county boards be paying tax on this?

Donald Trump · 17-12-2023 6:36pm

If he didn't do a "call out" video, then I'm not interested.

Gregor Samsa · 17-12-2023 9:13pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506873#Comment_121506873

Some details about the potential tax situation:

https://www.irishtimes.com/sport/gaelic-games/2023/12/14/how-much-each-gaa-club-will-receive-following-jp-mcmanuss-32m-donation/

short answer is no, you don’t pay tax on the receipt of a charitable donation.

mulbot · 17-12-2023 9:19pm

And the biggest tax dodger of all, the Irish Catholic church,who do actually reside here, never give a penny out-

JP Liz V1 · 17-12-2023 9:51pm

I thought it was about Joe Duffy 🙈

Joe Brolly thinks GAA after all the money they can get and who would buy on old stadium seat

https://www.thesun.ie/sport/11861054/joe-brolly-gaa-croke-park-cusack-stand-seats/

I suppose local small clubs could go with help and investment

breezy1985 · 17-12-2023 10:07pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506410#Comment_121506410

Many billionaires did. It's just Limerick spent it better. Let's not forget Clare had Kinnerk and told him to fek off.

Kerry Group for Kerry, O'Donnell in Clare, Brady's, O'Carrolls, Supermacs, the Yank from Leitrim, Barry's Tea in Cork, O'Moore's, Aronmore, Kingspan etc.

The vast majority of GAA sponsorship is philanthropy based or geographically based. I'm on the "pay your taxes in Ireland" side but to ball your eyes out like a baby because Limerick are winning is just pathetic.

Danzy · 17-12-2023 11:15pm

What limits my interest in Joe Brolly. Is that there is always something wrong with him.

When someone is always complaining, it's hard to pay attention.

coolshannagh28 · 17-12-2023 11:36pm

Who is bawling ? I really don't care either way ...The sponsors you mention mainly take the attitude of getting maximum exposure for the minimum investment as any business would , JP as a fan and philanthropist focused millions of investment in Limerick and got results ...my point is that this seems to go against the ethos of the organisation in general ...the million for every county may be his way of giving balance but is that giving big money too much power in an amateur sport .

ohnonotgmail · 17-12-2023 11:50pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506410#Comment_121506410

So, complaining that he gave too much to limerick and still complaining when he gives an equal amount to each county? That sounds like Joe Brolly alright.

chrisd2019 · 18-12-2023 12:03am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/2058327259/joe-calls-jp-out

Man who gets paid, to fill a sheet of paper or a webpage tries to grab some attention for himself. Am sure JP will not be too worried about it to be honest.

coolshannagh28 · 18-12-2023 12:08am

TBF he gave millions to Limerick...a millìon to every other county.

randd1 · 18-12-2023 10:16am

Joe Brolly loves to see Joe Brolly write articles about Joe Brolly for media exposure for Joe Brolly.

18-12-2023 2:32pm

some say Joe brolly holds the record for the most amount of blocked Twitter users. The man doesn’t like to be questioned.

i got blocked for asking about the well known video doing the rounds of him in a lap dancing club groping a woman when he was married. It was in reply to a vomit inducing article about Derry club football where he championed wholesome small village ethos, complete opposite to the video of him.

bnt · 18-12-2023 4:28pm

Headline kinda assumes we know these people without their full names. I first thought it was Joe Rogan calling out Jordan Peterson.

MIKEKC · 18-12-2023 11:59pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121506242#Comment_121506242

If Ireland is a tax haven why are these people moving abroad?

Jack Daw · 19-12-2023 12:22am

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121512411#Comment_121512411

It's a tax haven for a lot of international companies.

Seth Brundle · 19-12-2023 12:35am

Whatever people think about Brolly, is he wrong and, if so, why? (Personally I think he is 100% correct in calling out a tax exile when they try and buy their way)

blackwhite · 19-12-2023 4:42pm

Brolly knows better (or should know better) than the average journalist in terms what Non-Resident tax status actually means, but instead he's happy to paint a false picture to get a few more clicks on his articles.

Non-resident status means that McManus still has to pay Irish tax on any Irish incomes that he has and on any capital gains from selling Irish properties. It just means that his non-Irish incomes (such as those earned in the USA, the UK or in Switzerland) aren't subject to Irish taxes. The moral outrage over Ireland not being able to tax incomes from other jurisdictions is a joke.

Are we arguing that every Irish emigrant in London, Sydney or Vancouver should be paying Irish taxes on their English, Australian or Canadian incomes also?

buried · 19-12-2023 7:45pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121512515#Comment_121512515

If he's so concerned about tax exiles, why is he limiting his concern solely to McManus?

Seth Brundle · 19-12-2023 8:32pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121515482#Comment_121515482

That's whataboutery. He is a GAA pundit and he is criticising a tax exile (despite his claims to the contrary!) who is buying favour by giving money to areas of his own choosing which in this case is the GAA. What other tax exiles are currently donating significant amounts of money to Irish sporting bodies?

buried · 19-12-2023 8:44pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121515619#Comment_121515619

Whataboutery my crack. He WAS a GAA pundit. He is currently a pontificating loud mouth spewing out whatever takes his fancy from day to day.

As I've said, If he's so f**king concerned about the tax intake of this country, how literally the richest corporations on the planet use this country as a tax haven for THEIR own ends, why wasn't he pontificating about that for the last 30 years? Show me where he did it.

You can't, So it's not about tax exiles then, is it?

So spare me your own "whatabaddery"!

Seth Brundle · 19-12-2023 9:17pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121515655#Comment_121515655

He is still a pundit whether you like it or not - you clearly dont like him but again that doesn't mean he is not a GAA pundit. That he is no longer on RTE does not mean that he is no longer a pundit. Sure even his role at the Indo is all about GAA...

https://www.independent.ie/tag/joe-brolly

As for his article - this was in relation to the GAA and how one tax exile is donating money to it. Why would he comment on rich corporations given that they aren't giving money to the GAA?

buried · 19-12-2023 9:27pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121515780#Comment_121515780

I know full well he's a "pundit". But he is not a sole "pundit" of the GAA is he? What else has he been currently being a "pundit" about? Plenty of current affairs that have nothing to do with the GAA. So he wants to be up in everything concerned with the state of the nation, yes? If he's so concerned about tax exiles and how they affect the country, why is he only concerned about it now? Why wasn't he concerned about it the last 30 years, he's had plenty ample opportunity.

He wasn't concerned about it because he isn't concerned about it. All that concerns him is being a pathetic pundit.

ballyharpat · 20-12-2023 2:38pm

https://www.boards.ie/discussion/comment/121507685#Comment_121507685

I believe they have lots of Catholic charities that donate to many different areas and provide funding for Catholic volunteers.

https://www.catholicireland.net/organisations/

Hotblack Desiato · 21-12-2023 2:22pm

Yeah and how much just gets funnelled back to Rome?

Beasty · 21-12-2023 3:30pm

Thread title updated to reflect what the OP seems to want everyone else to discuss

Joe Brolly calls JP McManus out over GAA donations

Comments

Being young is a great advantage, since we see the world from a new perspective and we are not afraid to make radical changes - Greta Thunburg